.svg){kind=icon}
Back to blogs
July 17, 2025
//
Accounting
Payroll
Providing a company car is a powerful tool for attracting and retaining talent, but it opens up a complex world of tax obligations for UK employers. Our definitive guide for employers demystifies the entire process. We'll walk you through calculating the BIK value, explain the costly fuel benefit trap to avoid, and detail your essential reporting duties to HMRC. Learn how to make strategic, tax-efficient choices for when offering a company car as an incentive.
Having a company car continues to be one of the top employee benefits in the UK. It provides employees with convenience and financial predictability, while for businesses, it serves as a vital operational resource and a key factor in attracting and keeping staff. However, this valuable benefit involves complex tax responsibilities that employers must handle. Understanding these rules thoroughly is essential for ensuring compliance and controlling expenses.
This guide is tailored for UK employers, offering a detailed overview of their liabilities, reporting responsibilities, and strategic choices regarding company car benefits. It covers the basics of benefit in kind (BIK), detailed calculations for the car and fuel benefits, and explores alternatives to the conventional company car scheme.
At the heart of company car taxation is the concept of a benefit in kind. When an employer provides an employee or director with a non-cash benefit that has a monetary value, such as a vehicle for personal use, HMRC classifies this as a form of remuneration. This ‘perk’ is not tax-free but rather has a taxable cash equivalent value that must be calculated and reported annually to HMRC. Although the concept of annually reporting BIKs is due to change in 2027. To learn more about benefits in kind, click here.
The entire company car tax system relies on a single, essential factor: whether the car is available for private use by the employee. This is an important distinction that many employers often overlook. The tax charge does not depend on the actual private miles driven by an employee, but rather on the fact that the car is accessible for non-business trips.
HMRC's definition of private use is broad and explicitly includes an employee's regular commute between their home and the usual place of work. Therefore, unless a car is strictly forbidden from all private use according to the employment terms and this ban is effectively enforced, or it falls under the strict 'pool car' regulations, it will be regarded as a taxable benefit.
A single company car benefit creates two distinct and separate tax liabilities that must be understood and managed.
The total cost to the business of providing a company car is therefore not limited to the purchase or lease payments and running costs like insurance and maintenance. It must also include the direct, unrecoverable tax cost of Class 1A NICs. When a business chooses a car for an employee, the characteristics of that car (particularly its CO2 emissions) directly determine the BIK value. A higher BIK value results in a larger income tax bill for the employee, but it also creates a larger, separate tax bill for the employer. This dual financial impact makes the choice of vehicle a critical strategic decision for the business itself.
Class 1A NICs are a specific type of National Insurance that employers are liable to pay on the majority of benefits in kind that they provide to their employees, such as company cars. The government sets the rate and is subject to change.
The applicable rates are as follows:
The calculation for the employer’s liability is straightforward, once the car’s BIK value has been determined:
Employer’s Class 1A NICs = Car’s BIK value x Class 1A NIC rate
For example, if a company car has a calculated BIK value of £10,000 for the year:
It’s important to note that the planned rise in the Class 1A NIC rate from 13.8% to 15% in April 2025 aligns with a scheduled annual 1% increase (from 23%) for petrol and diesel cars. While a cap limits this year's percentage increase to 37%, it still results in a significant compounding effect, amplifying the overall cost for employers.
However, if we use a fully electric vehicle with a P11D value of £40,000, the numbers are significantly different:
In this scenario, the employer’s direct tax cost for providing the exact same vehicle increases by over 63% in a single year. This demonstrates why forward planning and budgeting for fleet replacement cycles are crucial for managing business costs effectively.
In summary, the benefit in kind for EVs is significantly lower than for petrol cars because it is based on the vehicle's CO2 emissions. However, the tax treatment for EVs is set to change in later years; see the section ‘Future-proofing your fleet: the road ahead to 2030’ of this article for more details.
The entire tax liability for both the employer and employee hinges on the correct calculation of the car's BIK value. This figure is the foundation upon which all subsequent tax calculations are built. The formula is:
BIK value = P11D value x appropriate percentage (BIK rate)
Defining the P11D value
The P11D value is the official price of the car for tax purposes. It is not the price the company paid for the vehicle, nor is it the car's value at the end of the tax year. It is a specific figure derived from the car's price when it was first registered.
The P11D value includes:
The P11D value excludes:
An important adjustment can be made if the employee makes a financial contribution towards the purchase of the car. If an employee contributes towards the capital cost, this amount (up to a maximum of £5,000) can be deducted from the P11D value before the BIK calculation is performed. The reason an employee would do this is to reduce their income tax liability. Any payments made by the employee for the private use of the car during the year are deducted at a later stage from the final BIK value.
The 'appropriate percentage', or BIK rate, is the multiplier that determines what proportion of the car's P11D value is treated as a taxable benefit. These percentages are set by HMRC and are structured to incentivise the use of vehicles with a lower environmental impact. A combination of three key factors determines the rate:
To determine the appropriate percentage for company car benefits for the 2024/25 tax year, you can refer to the government guidance, which provides a table breaking down the details above.
Did you know that you also have to pay tax if you pay for your employees' fuel when they are using the car for personal reasons? Although not as common, employers must be aware of a separate and substantial tax charge that arises if they provide fuel for an employee’s private use. This is known as the car fuel benefit charge.
This charge is triggered if an employer pays for any fuel that is used for an employee's private journeys in a company car, which includes their regular commute. If even a single litre of fuel for private travel is provided without being fully reimbursed by the employee, the full fuel benefit charge for the entire tax year applies. There is no pro-rata adjustment for partial reimbursement.
The fuel benefit is not based on the actual cost of the fuel provided; instead, it is calculated using a fixed formula designed to act as a strong deterrent.
Fuel benefit = fuel benefit multiplier x car’s appropriate percentage
The ‘fuel benefit multiplier’ is a fixed figure set by the government each tax year, which you can find here. Once the fuel benefit is calculated, it is treated as an additional taxable benefit. This means the employer must pay Class 1A NICs on the full amount, and the employee must pay income tax on it.
For example, consider a petrol car with a BIK rate of 25% in the 2024/25 tax year, where the employer provides a fuel card for all fuel.
The total tax cost of providing this "free" fuel is £3,739.10 (£959.10 for the employer and £2,780 for the employee). It is highly improbable that the employee would have spent £2,780 of their own post-tax income on private fuel during the year. This demonstrates that providing a fuel card for private use is almost always a financially inefficient arrangement for both parties; the tax cost frequently exceeds the real-world value of the fuel consumed.
The most effective strategy is to avoid the fuel benefit charge entirely. This can be achieved if the employee fully reimburses the employer for the cost of all fuel used for private journeys during the tax year. To do this correctly, the employer and employee must maintain meticulous and contemporaneous mileage records that clearly distinguish between business and private mileage.
The electric vehicle exception
A major advantage of electric vehicles in the current tax system is that the fuel benefit charge does not apply to electricity. An employer can pay for the electricity to charge a company EV, including at public charging points or installing and paying for a charger at the employee's home, without creating any taxable fuel benefit for the employee. This represents a significant additional tax-free benefit for providing electric vehicles as company cars. Please note that the car must be fully electric, as this exception does not apply to hybrid vehicles.
When providing benefits in kind, the employer must submit forms P11D and P11D(b) to HMRC. We have helpful blogs going in more detail about these forms here and here.
While the traditional model of providing a company car remains a popular choice, it’s worth familiarising yourself with some alternatives.
These rates are designed to cover all the employee's running costs, including fuel, insurance, servicing, and depreciation. These payments are a tax-deductible expense for the employer and are received entirely tax-free by the employee. It is important to note that an employee's commute to their normal place of work is not considered a business journey and cannot be claimed under AMAP. This method is ideal for employees who do not require a full-time company car but need to undertake occasional business travel.
If a vehicle qualifies as a 'pool car', it is entirely exempt from benefit in kind taxation. This means there is no income tax for any employee who drives it and no Class 1A NICs for the employer. To qualify, a car must satisfy all five of the following conditions:
The burden of proof to demonstrate that all five conditions have been met lies entirely with the employer. This is one of the most common areas for challenge during an HMRC compliance inspection. A common point of failure is the "overnight" rule; HMRC guidance suggests that if a car is taken home by employees on more than 60% of nights in a given period, it will likely fail this test.
Failure to satisfy even one of these conditions can lead to the exemption being denied retrospectively. This can result in HMRC raising assessments for back-dated income tax and penalties against every employee who used the car, and a significant bill for Class 1A NICs, interest, and penalties for the employer. To defend a pool car's status, an employer must maintain meticulous records, including:
The tax implications of company cars extend beyond BiK to Value Added Tax (VAT) and Corporation Tax.
VAT on car purchase and leasing
VAT on Running Costs
Corporation Tax
The costs associated with providing a company car are generally allowable as a business expense, reducing the company's taxable profits and therefore its Corporation Tax liability. These deductible expenses include the lease payments, running costs (such as insurance, servicing, and repairs), and the Class 1A NICs paid by the employer on the car and fuel benefits. For purchased cars, the cost can be claimed against profits through the capital allowances system.
The current company car tax regime offers substantial incentives for adopting zero and ultra-low emission vehicles. However, the government has already legislated for these tax advantages to be gradually tapered in the coming years as the EV market matures. Employers must consider these future changes when making long-term fleet decisions. Please keep in mind that legislation is constantly changing, and the information provided below was accurate at the date the article was published, but may have changed.
The BIK rates for the greenest cars are set to rise incrementally:
Considering that company car lease agreements typically last three or four years, a vehicle choice made today will have tax implications affected by these pre-announced rate increases. This is important to consider when budgeting for the future of your business.
Conclusion
The taxation of company cars in the UK is a multifaceted area that demands careful attention from employers and although we tried to be as thorough as possible, nothing replaces proper advice from an accountant. If you have any further questions or would like to discuss anything else, get in touch with us here.
Subscribe to our accounting newsletter for expert tips, valuable insights and the latest compliance updates written to help boost your financial knowledge and remain more informed.
hello@folio.partners
0203 727 0278
